| 2023 | |
| Conner Wilson | William Carey University |
| Kade May | Belhaven University |
| Cooper Williams | Belhaven University |
| 2022 | |
| Tom Biggs | Stephen F. Austin University |
| Kenner Bizot | Mississippi College |
| Brady Spring | Freed-Hardeman University |
| Lance Elsen | Newman University |
| Braydon Muse | Belhaven University |
| Reed Barlow | Belhaven University |
| 2021 | |
| Marquez Hudson | University of West Alabama |
| Tucker Jones | Belhaven University |
| Rhett Blackburn | Central Baptist College |
| Peyton Parker | Stephen F. Austin |
| Hunter Estes | Belhaven University |
| Caleb Rutledge | Stephen F. Austin |
| 2020 | |
| Cameron Hill | Blue Mountain College |
| Clint Stephens | Louisiana College |
| Brooks Italiano | Mississippi College |
| Konner Allen | William Carey University |
| Trey Frierson | Union University |
| Brandon Brown | University of Mobile |
| Trey Forsythe | University of Arkansas-Monticello |
| Joshua Day | University of Missouri |
| 2019 | |
| Conner Ingram | Spring Hill College |
| Austin Tidwell | Louisiana Tech |
| Ryan Zimmerman | Northwestern State University |
| Kevin Wright | Blue Mountain College |
| 2018 | |
| Justin Hutton | Arkansas Monticello |
| Jordan Bowden | Arkansas Monticello |
| Anthony Clapp | Spring Hill College |
| Christian day | Delta State University |
| Hayden White | Delta State University |
| CJ Estave | Delta State University |
| Jaylyn Williams | Jackson State University |
| Chandler Dillard | Jackson State University |
| Blake Sigrest | Blue Mountain College |
| Tyler Etheridge | Blue Mountain College |
| Kyle Whittington | Belhaven University |
| 2017 | |
| JT Wright | William Carey University |
| 2016 | |
| Jordan Antley | UT-Tyler |
| Miles Thomas | UT-Tyler |
| Jeremy Moore | UT-Tyler |
| Austin Douglas | Belhaven University |
| 2015 | |
| Adrian Brown | William Carey University |
| Stevie Hubbard | William Carey University |
| Shane Brown | Belhaven University |
| 2014 | |
| Mitch Little | William Carey University |
| Dominic Savage | Wiley College |
| 2013 | |
| Tyler Case | Mississippi Valley State |
| Jonathan Santana | University of New Orleans |
| Gabe Wilson | Belhaven University |
| Caleb Dugas | Northwestern State University |
| 2012 | |
| Stephen Joe | Christian Brothers University |
| Raymond Winter | University of New Orleans |
| Tyler Copeland | Belhaven University |
| Noel Santos | Central Michigan University |
| 2011 | |
| Bud Britt | Belhaven University |
| Edmund Cheatham | Mississippi Valley State |
| Brandon Jones | William Carey University |
| 2010 | |
| Jeff DiBlieux | University of South Alabama |
| Marshun Hall | Jackson State University |
| Kendall Logan | Jackson State University |
| Cable McMinn | Lambuth University |
| 2009 | |
| Cameron Logan | Texas State University |
| Brock Campbell | Mississippi College |
| Jared Rogers | William Carey University |
| Christian Malbrough | Florida International University |
| 2008 | |
| James Antoon | Louisiana College |
| Montez Chatman | William Carey University |
| Timmy Foster | Belhaven University |
| Steven Gauthe' | Nicholls State University |
| Brandt Hinton | Belhaven University |
| Avery Mathis | Louisiana College |
| Jordan Toney | Mississippi College |
| 2007 | |
| Brandon Chretien | William Carey University |
| 2006 | |
| Josh Logan | University of Louisiana-Lafayette |
| Xavier Qualls | Southeastern Louisiana University |
| Matthew Schexnayder | Southeastern Louisiana University |
| Derek Thompson | William Carey University |
| 2005 | |
| Colby Beach | Delta State University/Western Kentucky |
| Ryan Belanger | University of Southern Mississippi |
| Jody Britt | Mississippi College |
| Patrick Williams | Delta State University |
| 2004 | |
| Cass Brister | University of Montevello |
| Casey Ginn | William Carey University |
| Aaron Guillot | University of Montevello |
| Diego Nucete | Texas A&M - Kingsville |
| Tyler Perrett | University of Southern Mississippi |
| Jeffrey Waycaster | Mississippi College |
| Cole Zumbro | University of Montevello/Mississippi College |
| 2003 | |
| Chase Coley | Belhaven University |
| Kendall Poole | William Carey University |
| Cayce Wallace | Mississippi College |
| 2002 | |
| Derek Atkins | Mississippi State University |
| Kyle Beal | Coastal Carolina University |
| Arlandus Brown | University of West Alabama |
| David Gray | University of New Orleans |
| Jacob Hartwig | Belhaven University |
| Matt Lea | University of West Alabama |
| Seth Lofton | University of West Alabama |
| 2001 | |
| Brandon Atkins | Southeastern Louisiana University |
| Doug Atkins | Troy State University |
| Jacob Blakeney | Mississippi State University |
| Josh Garrett | University of Southern Mississippi |
| Britt Hederman | William Carey University |
| Chuckie Stracener | Lyon College |
| 2000 | |
| Christopher Dunn | University of Southern Mississippi |
| Jessie Fuller | Belhaven University |
| Edison Lee | Campbell University |
| Josh McNulty | William Carey University |
| Daniel Mouton | Campbell University |
| Ryan Neely | Mississippi Valley State |
| Lance Newman | Troy State University |
| Hunter Ogden | Belhaven University |
| 1999 | |
| Joseph Paul | Southeastern Louisiana University |
| Brent Quinn | University of Southern Mississippi |
| 1998 | |
| Brian Barlow | Belhaven University |
| Brandon Belanger | Tulane University |
| Colby Calcote | University of Southern Mississippi |
| Casey Edwards | Mississippi College |
| Lee Molaison | Nicholls State University |
| 1997 | |
| Trey Day | University of South Alabama |
| Chris Hills | Jackson State University |
| Eric Stokes | Belhaven University |
| 1996 | |
| Brad Harvill | Belhaven University |
| Jeremy Neyland | University of Southwestern Louisiana |
| Chard Bryant | William Carey University |
| Mark Jones | Belhaven University |
| Danny Shupe | University of Southern Mississippi |
| 1995 | |
| Chad Caillet | University of Southern Mississippi |
| Brannon Cobb | University of Southern Mississippi |
| Jason Kinchen | Brewton-Parker College |
| 1994 | |
| Shannon Ballard | University of Southern Mississippi |
| Chris Weekley | University of Southern Mississippi |
| Brandon Barlow | Millsaps College |
| 1993 | |
| Joey Durr | Mississippi College |
| Ron Rushing | Delta State University |
| Kennon Lavergne | Belhaven University |
| Johnny Van Hoose | Belhaven University |